Rutgers‑Eagleton Poll Shows New Jersey Residents Rank New York Drivers as Worst

In a recent statewide poll conducted by Rutgers‑Eagleton, New Jersey voters identified New York as having the worst drivers, with a staggering 33 % of respondents agreeing. While New Jersey itself wasn’t far behind—22 % of voters blamed their own state for road safety woes—the poll also shed light on how attitudes toward driving vary across the region and what it means for motorists in New York, New Jersey, and neighboring states. Below we unpack the findings, examine the methodology, and offer practical tips for all drivers who want to improve their habits on the road.

Understanding the Poll’s Landscape

The survey, completed January 2025, reached 795 registered voters through live telephone call and text message. Respondents were asked to rate drivers in several states on a scale from “excellent” to “worst.” The 15‑point margin of error (+/- 4.6 %) means the rankings likely reflect broad sentiment rather than isolated anecdotes.

Key Results at a Glance

• New York drivers: 33 % rated as the worst
  New Jersey drivers: 22 % rated as the worst
  Pennsylvania drivers: 14 % rated as the worst
  Florida drivers: 10 % rated as the worst
• When stratifying by education, respondents with some college or less were almost evenly split between New York and New Jersey as worst drivers.
• Political leanings influenced perceptions: Republicans (29 %) and independents (23 %) blamed New Jersey more than Democrats (14 %). Democrats, conversely, were more likely to blame Florida.

Methodology Matters

The poll was performed via a registered‑voter sample to avoid partisan bias and included various demographic slices—gender, age, income, and ethnicity. Using live calling plus texting ensured a broad, modern reach. However, respondents were asked to recall typical driving experiences, which can introduce self‑reporting bias.

What Drives These Perceptions?

Several factors paint the picture of “worst drivers” for New York and New Jersey alike:

• Congestion and Infrastructure – Both states struggle with high traffic volumes and aging roadways that can encourage impatient or distracted driving.
• Policy and Enforcement – New York’s stricter speed limits and aggressive traffic policing sometimes result in harsher judgment of drivers, compared with the relatively less frequent enforcement in New Jersey.
• Cross‑border Traffic – Drivers from New York often navigate New Jersey’s complex freeway systems, leading to frustration on both sides.
• Media Representation – Frequent coverage of New York traffic incidents can reinforce negative stereotypes.

Is the Data About Driving Habits or Stereotypes?

While the poll offers a snapshot of public perception, it doesn’t quantify actual accident rates or driver behavior. In fact, state traffic reports often show similar or even lower incident rates in New Jersey compared to New York, suggesting that “worst drivers” can be more about sentiment than statistics.

Turning Perception into Action

Drivers in both states can use these findings—no matter how negative or lighthearted—to improve personal safety and contribute to a better driving culture.

1. Adopt Strong Defensive Driving Habits

The most reliable way to mitigate risk is to keep a defensive stance behind the wheel. Here are concrete habits:

1. Maintain a safe following distance. Use the three‑second rule (or more in wet conditions).
2. Stay focused on the road. Keep mobile devices out of reach and limit conversations with passengers.
3. Respect traffic signals and speed limits. Set in‑app alerts or dedicated GPS that notifies you of speed limit changes.
4. Be patient with merged or cut‑in traffic. Use a blind‑spot check before changing lanes and never assume a cut‑in driver’s intent.

Following these steps reduces the likelihood that a driver will be seen as “worst.” It also helps build a reputation for reliable, courteous driving.

2. Leverage Technology to Improve Habit Tracking

Modern vehicles can now log driving patterns—speeding, harsh braking, rapid acceleration. Many insurance companies offer telematics discounts for safe driving. Even a smartphone app can track seat‑belt usage and cell‑phone misuse. If you’re a frequent commuter in New York or New Jersey, consider a device that logs your trips and share the data with your insurer.

3. Engage in Community and State Initiatives

Both states run safety campaigns that encourage better driving. New York’s “Drive Safe Day” and New Jersey’s “Drive With Confidence” programs offer free seat‑belt checks, educational webinars, and safety pledges. Enrolling is straightforward—check the state transportation website for local events or call the hotline.

4. Invest in Defensive Driving Courses

State‑approved defensive driving courses are often available for less than $200. They can improve your skills while also lowering insurance premiums. Look for accredited instructors through the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) or the New Jersey Department of Transportation.

5. Advocate for Better Infrastructure and Policy

When state legislators discuss traffic legislation, drivers can submit testimony or join local advocacy groups. Supporting policy changes—such as improved signage, expanded biking lanes, or stricter DUI limits—helps elevate overall road safety. Contact your local representative’s office to learn how.

What the Poll Means for Policy Makers

Given that a significant portion of respondents blamed political affiliation for driving quality, lawmakers have a clear directive: demonstrate tangible improvements in traffic enforcement and transportation planning to shift public perception. Initiatives that reduce congestion—such as improved public transit connectivity between New York and New Jersey—can also help reduce the frustration that often transforms into aggressive driving.

Future Research Directions

While this poll shines a light on public sentiment, new studies that incorporate accident databases, traffic camera footage, and insurance claim data would provide a fuller picture. Combining quantitative crash data with qualitative surveys could highlight whether self‑reporting bias is inflating perceived negativity.

Take Action Today

Whether you’re a New Jersey commuter or a New York resident crossing the state line daily, the way forward is the same: focus on your own driving habits, support local safety initiatives, and share best practices. Use the poll’s insights to advocate for safer roads—both for yourself and your community.

Ready to improve your driving credentials?

• Schedule a free safety workshop with your local transportation office.
• Enroll in a state‑approved defensive driving course.
• Check out New Jersey’s latest road safety statistics and reports.
• Join the ‘Drive Safe’ community campaigns in New York.

Let the Rutgers‑Eagleton poll be a conversation starter, not a verdict. With improved habits, community support, and informed policy, both New York and New Jersey can move toward safer, more reliable driving cultures.